If you’ve got a big extended family or a busy school party calendar, you’ll know how quickly the cost of kids’ birthday presents adds up. With toy prices climbing and kids always wanting the latest trend, it can put a serious dent in your monthly budget.
Here are the simple, common-sense ways we save money on kids’ birthday gifts while still giving great presents.
And don’t forget birthday freebies. Lots of places give kids a free treat on their birthday, like Build-A-Bear’s pay-your-age offer.

Table of Contents
1. Tap Into Your “Unopened Stash” (The Re-Gifting Secret)
When my kids were younger, relatives and friends would kindly gift them toys for birthdays and Christmas. Like many parents, we’d set some of those presents aside for a “rainy day” or for when the kids were a little bit older.
Fast-forward through the months and years, and what happens? The kids grew up, moved on to new interests, and a whole collection of brand-new, completely untouched, mint-condition toys ended up stored away in the loft!
Instead of letting those unopened items gather dust forever:
- Audit Your Storage: Go up into the loft, check the back of the wardrobes, or dig through the spare room cupboards.
- Create a Gift Stash: Put aside anything that is still factory-sealed, completely unused, and in perfect condition.
- Re-Gift with Confidence: When the next party invitation arrives, check your hidden stash first before heading to the high street or ordering online.
Giving a brand-new, unopened item from your stash isn’t being tight—it’s smart financial management and one of the easiest ways to cut the cost of birthday presents.
2. Source “Like-New” Bargains Online
If you don’t have an unopened stash in your loft, you don’t have to pay full retail price at big toy stores either. Using second-hand apps is another clever way to get brand-new presents for less.
In previous posts, we’ve talked about using online marketplaces to find unbelievable bargains:
- Vinted & eBay: You can filter search results specifically by condition (“New with tags” or “New in box”). People frequently sell duplicate birthday gifts or unopened items for a fraction of the original store price.
- Facebook Marketplace: Perfect for local pick-ups where you can inspect the condition in person before handing over any cash.
3. The Mindset Shift: Stop Wasting Unused Items
We often feel obligated to rush out and spend £15–£30 every time a party invitation drops through the door. But taking a step back to look at what you already own—or hunting for brand-new items second-hand—stops unnecessary money from leaving your bank account.
That saved £20 or £30 stays right where it belongs: in your household budget, ready to feed your emergency fund or pay down your essential bills.
Cheap First Birthday Gift Ideas (and What We Did Instead)
For both of our kids’ first birthdays, we made a decision that saved us money and stress: we didn’t buy them a present ourselves. We knew friends and family would be getting them lots of gifts, and a one-year-old is just as happy with the wrapping paper. Instead, we each put £100 into a savings account for them.
Both of our kids now have a NatWest children’s savings account, and that’s still where their birthday money goes every year.
If you do want to buy something, here are some cheap first birthday gift ideas that babies genuinely enjoy:
- Board books and lift-the-flap books, which are cheap new and even cheaper second-hand.
- Nearly-new toys from Facebook Marketplace or Vinted. At one, they won’t know or care that it isn’t brand new.
- Simple toys like stacking cups, shape sorters and a ball. They often get more play than expensive electronic toys.
- A keepsake, like a handprint or footprint kit or a photo book, which costs little but means a lot.
- A day out. Lots of places let babies in free, so you only pay for the adults.
- A savings gift. Starting (or adding to) a children’s savings account is a present that grows, just like we did.
Tip: if family ask what to buy, share a short wish list so you don’t end up with three of the same toy.
What are your gift-saving wins? Do you have a hidden stash of unopened presents in your loft or spare room? Have you ever re-gifted an item to save money on a family birthday? Let me know your top tips in the comments below!
Is it socially acceptable to re-gift unopened items for a child’s birthday?
Yes, as long as the item is brand new, factory-sealed, and in mint condition. Re-gifting unused toys prevents waste, saves money, and gives the recipient a great brand-new present.
How can I find brand-new kids’ gifts on second-hand apps like Vinted or eBay?
Use the search filters to select condition categories such as “New with tags” or “New in box.” Many sellers list duplicate birthday gifts or unopened items for significantly less than retail price.
What is a good cheap first birthday gift?
Board books, simple toys like stacking cups or a shape sorter, nearly-new toys from Vinted or Facebook Marketplace, and a handprint keepsake are all cheap first birthday gifts babies enjoy. Putting money into a children’s savings account is another option. For our kids’ first birthdays, we each put £100 into savings instead of buying a present.